Opposes: the 20,000 figure is an untested federal estimate. California says no evidence or method was shared, a similar Nevada list turned out to be citizens, the count fell from 190,000, and no court has found any of the 20,000 ineligible.
Secretary of State Shirley Weber says DOJ has not supplied evidence or methodology, and notes a federal list of about 16,000 suspected noncitizens in Nevada proved to be citizens. The administration's own number dropped from 190,000 in the summer to 20,000, and its voter-roll lawsuits have mostly failed. Noncitizen voting prosecutions remain rare, with about 50 charged nationally this year.The claim rests on a list nobody outside the federal government has checked. Weber told DOJ it had not provided evidence for the 20,000 figure and was acting on "unverifiable information or methodology that you still fail to explain or provide" (AP via PBS). She cited Nevada, where nearly 16,000 people flagged by federal officials were all found to be US citizens.
The number has moved a lot. Attorney General Rob Bonta noted that DHS claimed 190,000 noncitizens on the rolls over the summer, and now DOJ says 20,000. He also said federal law prohibits states from changing voter rolls within 90 days of an election.
The track record is weak. CBS reports that the Civil Rights Division has filed 31 suits to obtain voter rolls and lost 26 without a win (CBS News). The list reached Los Angeles County on a thumb drive with a handwritten password, and the registrar refused to open it as insecure. AP reports DOJ has charged about 50 people nationwide this year with voting as noncitizens, against more than 227 million registered voters in 2024.
Limits. California has not checked the list either, so it has not disproved it. DOJ cites 28 people from the list charged on Oct 19. The government says USCIS and HSI used several verification methods, and a court may yet test them.