Opposes: the evidence does not show white South Africans are persecuted for their race. Five of six farm murder victims in early 2025 were Black, farm killings are a tiny share of murders, and many Afrikaners reject the genocide claim.

South African police recorded six murders in farming communities from January to March 2025, and CBS reports five of the victims were Black. An estimated 37 people were killed on farms in 2024, against more than 25,000 murders nationally. Afrikaners interviewed by 60 Minutes, including the widow of a murdered farmer, described farm attacks as crimes of opportunity, not genocide.
Benjamin Toby
Benjamin Toby·1mo

Persecution means being targeted because of who you are. The available data show violent crime that falls on all South Africans, not a campaign aimed at white people.

South Africa's police rural safety statistics for January to March 2025 recorded six murders in farming communities: three farm employees, one farm dweller and two farmers. The government says these figures show "violent crime in rural areas affects everyone who lives and works on farms" (South African government). CBS's 60 Minutes reports that five of those six victims were Black, that an estimated 37 people were killed on farms in 2024 against more than 25,000 murders nationwide, and, citing an agricultural economist, that the vast majority of people operating South Africa's farms are Black (CBS News).

Many Afrikaners themselves reject the framing. The widow of a farmer murdered in 2024 told 60 Minutes that it was "not what I know as a genocide" and called it a crime of opportunity. Afrikaans journalist Max du Preez said he had never been discriminated against as a white South African. The farmer who placed the roadside crosses Trump showed as "burial sites" said they were a temporary memorial.

Limits. The government statement comes from an interested party and covers only three months. Police data do not record motive, and advocacy groups count farm attacks differently. Persecution can take forms short of killing, such as discriminatory policy, which murder data cannot rule out.

Exhibits

Evidence cited

South African government (DIRCO) statement on farm crime, Aug. 20, 2025gov.za
Under review
CBS News / 60 Minutes: South Africans dispute Trump's claim of genocidecbsnews.com
Under review

Discussion

Log in to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.