Opposes: the evidence points to natural spillover from animals, most likely via Wuhan's Huanan market. WHO's expert advisers found most peer-reviewed evidence supports a zoonotic origin, with early cases and two virus lineages tied to the market.

WHO's Scientific Advisory Group for the Origins of Novel Pathogens concluded in June 2025 that the weight of available evidence suggests zoonotic spillover, directly from bats or through an intermediate host. In a 2026 Nature comment, 23 members said more than 60 percent of the earliest known cases were linked to the market, two lineages were found there, and samples showed susceptible animals such as raccoon dogs had been present. SAGO found no scientific evidence that the virus was deliberately manipulated.
Benjamin Toby
Benjamin Toby·1mo

The most thorough independent review, by 27 independent experts convened by WHO, concluded that "the weight of available evidence reviewed by SAGO suggests zoonotic spillover of SARS-CoV-2 into the human population, either directly from bats or through an intermediate host," with the Huanan Seafood Market the apparent site of early amplification. It found no scientific evidence that the virus had been deliberately manipulated and said such claims are "not supported by accurate science" (SAGO assessment).

In February 2026, 23 of the original members set out the evidence in Nature (Nature):

  • more than 60 percent of the known earliest cases in December 2019 had an epidemiological link to the market;
  • two distinct viral lineages were found in early market-linked cases and in environmental samples from stalls and drains, suggesting the virus was already evolving in animals;
  • genetic material from wildlife species including raccoon dogs was found at the market before it was cleaned;
  • no verified human or animal infection has been found anywhere before December 2019.

Limits. No infected animal has been found. SAGO says it cannot rule out a lab origin because the necessary information has not been provided. The Nature piece is the advisers defending their own conclusions, and some intelligence agencies lean the other way.

Exhibits

Evidence cited

SAGO: Independent assessment of the origins of SARS-CoV-2 (WHO, June 2025)cdn.who.int
Under review
Nature comment by 23 SAGO members, February 2026: the origin of SARS-CoV-2nature.com
Under review

Discussion

Log in to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.