Supports: Lucy Letby's convictions should stand. A jury convicted her after a ten-month trial, the Court of Appeal found none of her grounds arguable and refused fresh evidence, and a blood test showed a baby had been given insulin that no one prescribed.

In August 2023 a jury convicted Letby of seven murders and seven attempted murders, and the judge imposed whole-life orders. In July 2024 the Court of Appeal refused leave to appeal and declined to admit Dr Shoo Lee's fresh evidence. The Thirlwall Inquiry report sets out a laboratory result showing one baby had received insulin from an external source that had not been prescribed.
Benjamin Toby
Benjamin Toby·1mo

Letby's guilt is the current legal position, reached through the full criminal process. After a trial lasting more than ten months, a jury convicted her of seven murders and seven attempted murders, acquitted her on two counts and could not agree on others, which suggests it weighed each charge on its own evidence. Sentencing her, Mr Justice Goss found "pre-meditation, calculation and cunning" in her actions (sentencing remarks).

The Court of Appeal examined her grounds, including criticism of the prosecution experts' reliance on skin discolouration to diagnose air embolus. It agreed with the single judge that "none of the grounds advanced are arguable," heard Dr Shoo Lee give evidence, and held that the criteria for admitting his fresh evidence were not met (Court of Appeal, July 2024).

The insulin evidence does not depend on reading skin colour. The Thirlwall Inquiry summary records that one baby's blood showed insulin of 4,657 picomoles per litre with low C-peptide, a pattern that "does not happen when insulin is being produced naturally," and that no baby on the unit had been prescribed insulin (Thirlwall summary).

Limits. Thirlwall stated that its focus was not on Letby's guilt or convictions. Some experts argue the insulin test used needs confirmatory analysis. An international panel says the medical evidence does not support the convictions, and the CCRC is still reviewing the case.

Exhibits

Evidence cited

Sentencing remarks of Mr Justice Goss, R v Letby, Aug. 21, 2023judiciary.uk
Under review
Court of Appeal judgment refusing Letby leave to appeal, July 2, 2024judiciary.uk
Under review
Thirlwall Inquiry summary report, Sept. 15, 2026thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk
Under review

Discussion

Log in to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.