Opposes: Lucy Letby's convictions may be unsafe. An international panel of 14 experts found no medical evidence of deliberate harm, her so-called confession notes were reportedly written on counsellors' advice, and the CCRC is reviewing her case.
In February 2025 a panel of 14 neonatologists and paediatricians chaired by Dr Shoo Lee reported that the babies' deaths and collapses were explained by natural causes or poor care. The Guardian reported that the notes presented as confessions were written as a coping exercise and also contain protestations of innocence. The Criminal Cases Review Commission has received expert reports and submissions through January 2026 and has not yet decided.The prosecution rested heavily on expert interpretation of clinical events, and that interpretation is now under sustained challenge. In February 2025 an international panel of 14 experts, including a former president of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, said it found no evidence that Letby murdered or harmed any of the babies. Its 31-page summary attributed deaths and collapses to natural causes or poor medical care, and its chair, Dr Shoo Lee, said: "we did not find any murders" (Guardian).
The notes often cited as a confession are less clear than they look. The Guardian reported that they were written on the advice of counsellors as a way of coping with extreme stress, and that alongside "I am evil I did this" they say "I haven't done anything wrong" and describe suicidal despair (Guardian).
The Criminal Cases Review Commission, which refers cases to the Court of Appeal when new evidence or argument creates a real possibility a conviction will not be upheld, has received expert reports and submissions since February 2025, most recently in January 2026, and says a review is under way (CCRC).
Limits. The panel was convened at the suggestion of Dr Lee, whose earlier evidence the Court of Appeal declined to admit, and its findings have not been tested in court. The jury saw the notes and heard the defence. The CCRC has made no decision, and the convictions stand.