Supports: the Palestine Action ban is a justified counter-terrorism measure. The Court of Appeal found the group uses weapons to cause serious damage, works through secret cells and is concerned in terrorism, and MPs approved the ban 385 to 26.
On June 15, 2026 five Court of Appeal judges held the proscription lawful and proportionate, reversing the High Court. They found Palestine Action is not part of the tradition of peaceful protest but a covert organisation that damages property with weapons such as sledgehammers. The Commons had approved the order on July 2, 2025 by 385 votes to 26.The government's case is that Palestine Action crossed from protest into terrorism, and the most senior court to examine the open evidence agreed. The Court of Appeal found that the group (judgment, para. 13):
- is not engaged in the "well-established tradition of peaceful protest";
- is concerned in terrorism and causes serious damage to property with weapons including sledgehammers, presenting "very real risks of injury";
- published an "Underground Manual" in 2023 advocating destruction of targets and avoiding detection;
- ran an escalating campaign against businesses including defence firms supplying Ukraine and NATO.
It added that proscription helps stop the group funding terrorism and degrades its covert cell structure. Lady Chief Justice Carr said it was "a fundamental mistake to overlook the fact that Palestine Action overtly promotes unlawful violence amounting to terrorism," and that it is not a suffragette-style group operating in the open (BBC). The court also found the Home Secretary had followed her own policy and that evidence of an international consensus against such bans was "exiguous."
The decision also has democratic backing: the Commons approved the proscription order by 385 votes to 26 (division record).
Limits. The court accepted the ban may chill lawful support for the Palestinian cause. The High Court reached the opposite conclusion, part of the evidence is closed, and a Supreme Court appeal is being sought.