Opposes: Tyler Robinson's guilt has not been established. He is presumed innocent, his lawyers dispute the DNA evidence, a federal analysis could not link the fatal bullet to the rifle, and the alleged admissions have not been tested at trial.
A probable-cause ruling is not a verdict, and Robinson has pleaded not guilty to all counts. At the preliminary hearing his lawyers challenged how mixed DNA profiles were interpreted, and an ATF comparison of the bullet fragment from the autopsy with the rifle was inconclusive. The context and admissibility of his alleged messages, and any motive, remain to be tested.Any claim about this case has to start from the presumption of innocence. Binding a defendant over for trial requires only probable cause, a far lower standard than proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and none of the state's evidence has yet been tested before a jury.
The forensic case is contested. Defence lawyer Michael Burt cross-examined an FBI DNA analyst and argued: "She can't match Mr. Robinson to the questioned samples." The prosecutor himself said the results involved "explanations that are susceptible to different interpretations and arguments" and that reliability would be decided at trial (PBS/AP). Defence lawyers also questioned how the crime scene was handled.
The ballistics are not settled either. Court filings show an ATF examiner compared the bullet jacket fragment recovered at autopsy with the rifle and found the result "inconclusive" (PolitiFact via PBS). The prosecution's alleged admissions depend on messages and a note whose context and admissibility can still be challenged, and the defence argues the state cannot show what was in Robinson's mind.
Limits. Inconclusive does not mean the bullet failed to match. Experts told PolitiFact that damaged rifle fragments often cannot be identified either way. A state analyst testified DNA on the towel was very likely Robinson's, the video and alleged admissions remain, and the defence has not suggested another shooter. Claims of a second shooter have no support in the record.